@anantagdThe Yangsi Michael Dillon @nelsonNelson Lopez i genuinely don't know how to react to all of this.. or to do with this. your points are really good and i personally agree with them. i do think there's value in altbot for posts that would otherwise have nothing, but i also see how it might be doing more harm than good in ways i didn't anticipate. with the whole, people being lazy about it thing.

so i want to ask. what do you think i should do then? shut it down? change something about how it works? i swear im not trying to be defensive, i actually want to know what you personally think the right move is in this situation.

@micr0Micr0byte @nelsonNelson Lopez I cannot tell you what to do. Your intentions are excellent. However, whenever seeing people design a Something to improve accessibility for blind people, the result is often sub optimal, because often it's trying to meet needs that aren't there. And then only serves one aspect of that need, disregarding other aspects.

Also, the effect on blind people is perhaps not what you expected to happen. I'm not a "nice" blind person. When someone does the altbot thing and nothing else in my timeline, I think: I'm not worth the effort. Remember: I can't spot read: I need to listen to all of it, beginning to end. Nowadays I recognize alt bot output immediately, even when people have amended it somewhat, and I block them and move on.

An aspect you might consider: AltBot underscores the idea that providing alt text is a heavy burden on seeing people. And often such thinking makes "blind folks", "screen reader users" into an abstraction.

Alt text on Mastodon is a beautiful thing.

0
0
0

If you have a fediverse account, you can quote this note from your own instance. Search https://ieji.de/users/anantagd/statuses/115804884795795222 on your instance and quote it. (Note that quoting is not supported in Mastodon.)