After I chat with some people, I realized I have issues in understanding their concept of nostalgia.
It's some kind of magical thinking.
Something is cool, fun or worth the time/expense because it's old. Time passing imbues qualities into things.
A clone, a reproduction, something functionally identical, does not possess these qualities.
I would understand a "it doesn't have the same repairability or understandability" in regards to an FPGA implementation. I'd understand "it's just a more capable machine wasting cycles pretending to be something it's not" of an emulator.
1/..