Dumb question that I was always too afraid to ask:

I know how the #Fediverse and its federation works. It's intuitive and familiar to me; I mean, I even host my own instance.

But I never understood how interaction cross-software is supposed to work. In theory, I can use whatever #ActivityPub software I want and still interact with everyone else. But in practice that just... isn't the case, right?

I mean, for text it's quite simple: I write a short post on #Mastodon and people on #GoToSocial or #Misskey or whatever can see and read that same post and interact with it. They can see my profile and it appears on their instance in their style and with their features.

Even outside of microblogging I still get it. A super-long post on #Friendica or #Diaspora appears on my timeline, too. Their profiles might have more fields than I can see here, but that's fine.

But what's up beyond that?

I can see #Pixelfed posts here, converted into image galleries. But what about the other way 'round? If someone on Pixelfed follows my Mastodon account, they can't see any of my non-image posts, right?

What about #PeerTube and such niche software? I guess I could follow a PeerTube account as a microblogger and see their videos and descriptions in my timeline. Video comments are replies.

But the other way 'round? How are they supposed to interact with Friendica or Pixelfed users? PeerTube doesn't even have a "timeline".

Doesn't that feature disparity undermine the whole idea of the #Fediverse or am I missing something?

#AskFedi #FediAdmin

I am asking this because I caught myself thinking about making a Mastodon account for my PeerTube space, in the same way you used to make a Twitter presence for your YouTube channel.

I realised that I should be able to just use my PeerTube account instead, since it's ActivityPub. That's the whole appeal of the Fediverse!

But since I can't write text posts, read timelines or interact in any way with non-video content on PeerTube, where is the point in federating with the rest of ActivityPub?

Is it only for commenters to be able to use their existing Fedi accounts to comment on PeerTube, and it's more of a one-way thing in reality?

#PeerTube #Fediverse #Fedi #AskFedi

0

If you have a fediverse account, you can quote this note from your own instance. Search https://micro.webgarden.click/users/lianna/statuses/01K2Q31E3MDMFTE1DKPWWXDRVT on your instance and quote it. (Note that quoting is not supported in Mastodon.)