洪 民憙 (Hong Minhee) @hongminhee@hackers.pub
Public

After reviewing FEP-5624: Per-object reply control policies and GoToSocial's interaction policy spec, I find myself leaning toward the latter for long-term considerations, though both have merit.

FEP-5624 is admirably focused and simpler to implement, which I appreciate. However, 's approach seems to offer some architectural advantages:

  1. The three-tier permission model (allow/require approval/deny) feels more flexible than binary allow/deny
  2. Separating approval objects from interactions appears more secure against forgery
  3. The explicit handling of edge cases (mentioned users, post authors) provides clearer semantics
  4. The extensible framework allows for handling diverse interaction types, not just replies

I wonder if creating an that extracts GoToSocial's interaction policy design into a standalone standard might be worthwhile. It could potentially serve as a more comprehensive foundation for access control in .

This is merely my initial impression though. I'd be curious to hear other developers' perspectives on these approaches.

Summary card of repository fediverse/fep

fep/fep/5624/fep-5624.md at main

fep - Fediverse Enhancement Proposals

codeberg.org · Codeberg.org

4
1
1
James Ross

James Ross

@twpol@tech.lgbt

He/him. Cis/het. I like , , / , and the Oxford comma. Professional computer whisperer. C#/DotNet/JavaScript. Southern England, UK.

I do not post much myself but will boost interesting and insightful posts from as diverse a range of others as I can manage.

Previously:
Joined 2018-09 en.osm.town/@twpol
Joined 2022-04 mastodon.online/@twpol

fedicat

fedicat

@fedicat@pc.cafe

The official account for the fedicat fediverse iOS client available on testflight. I try to include other fediverse stuff to keep it interesting.

bgl gwyng

bgl gwyng

@bgl@hackers.pub

슈티를 함께 만들 팀을 만들고 있습니다. 관심 있으신 분, 또는 잘 모르겠지만 이야기를 나눠보고 싶은 분도 bgl@gwyng.com으로 편하게 연락주세요.

洪 民憙 (Hong Minhee)

洪 民憙 (Hong Minhee)

@hongminhee@hollo.social

An intersectionalist, feminist, and socialist guy living in Seoul (UTC+09:00). @tokolovesme금강토's spouse. Who's behind @fedifyFedify: an ActivityPub server framework, @holloHollo :hollo:, and @botkitBotKit by Fedify :botkit:. Write some free software in , , , & . They/them.

서울에 사는 交叉女性主義者이자 社會主義者. 金剛兔(@tokolovesme금강토)의 配偶者. @fedifyFedify: an ActivityPub server framework, @holloHollo :hollo:, @botkitBotKit by Fedify :botkit: 메인테이너. , , , 等으로 自由 소프트웨어 만듦.

()

Kye.br :terminal_blinker:

Kye.br :terminal_blinker:

@Kyebr@hachyderm.io

An entropic engine made if nurons.
Trying to discern the meanings of the life.

Aslak Raanes

Aslak Raanes

@aslakr@mastodon.social

Poster på norsk og noe engelsk. Booster (?) i tillegg ting som er på dansk, svensk og tysk.

Posts in Norwegian and English. Might boost posts in Danish, Swedish and some German.

🗺️ , 

🧑‍💻 



wakest ⁂

wakest ⁂

@liaizon@social.wake.st

A little birdie once told me: peep!
wake.st

Chee Aun 🤔

Chee Aun 🤔

@cheeaun@mastodon.social

Product-1st Front-end Engineer, based in Singapore. Currently on a career break since July '22. Working on a Mastodon web client phanpy.social @phanpy

Why follow me: I have interests in , , , , , & . I usually post about my side projects, tech events, weird discoveries, and sometimes local news.

tfr